I had a galleon scuttled during a Pirate run yesterday. Repairing it to 100% Pristine condition left it still showing damage & still being reported as scuttled. Today, after a Pirate hovering at the stern and firing cannons at me while my character was on the ship finally went elsewhere, I repaired the ship to 100% Pristine condition and it was still showing damage & being reported as scuttled by the pilot. I did emergency repairs and got it moving slowly towards port. After the emergency repairs wore out, the ships damage vanished and it jumped to full speed and is now fine.