I'm not sure how many fishermen there are in our crew. But here's a hint how ye can achieve yer goals and rewards more efficiently when ye work as a team: First, ye need a house with a fish-container accessible to the whole guild. Recall to one of the docks or to the Sea Market. Get the quest from one of the Fishmongers. Sail to the destination where ye have to deliver the required fish to. While sailing, constantly fish along. Once ye reach yer destination, leave yer vessel there, recall back to the house with the fish-container and store yer whole catch there. Take only the fish ye need to finish the quest out of the fish-container and recall back to yer boat. Finish the quest. By doing this, the guild's stock of fish will build faster than it is emptied, and everyone benefits from this. The more fishermen participating, the better. Is there any dedicated fisherman in our crew who wants to offer such a setup? It would be a great addition to our pirate village. The fish-container should only be communicated to the fishermen amongst us.