Ok my very first battle with Melissa, I got the cloak and the ticket. But about 20 go arounds later, I haven't gotten a second one. I'm using a pally archer, shooting her full of bolts with my Night Reaper crossbow. With EoO, CW and DF, a combo i can only do a 2-3 times, I hit her for about 45 points a second. Is it the TOP damager who gets the nod, or how many out of the group are usually included in the consideration? Because with the Greater Dragon tamers, I'll never be at the top. But I wager I'm at least in the top 5 out of 10 or so. Does this cut it? At least I'm making out like a bandit with the ingredients and gold... so even without the trinket it's still fun. Except for the law that every paragon balron will pick me out and never, ever untarget me.