The reason for this thread is to discuss the current usage of Enchanted Apples. Currently, this is the way it works: Eating an apple has a chance to remove a debuff. If it fails, you can eat another apple again right away. If it succeeds, it will go on cool down. The suggested change is this: Eating an apple will remove all debuffs. It can't fail, and will always go on cool down after usage. The change will do this: Put more responsibility on players for PVP (less RNG, more player skill) Make it that much harder for people to script auto-apples (u curse player, script removes curse, u mortal player, player cannot remove mortal) Scenario: A player gets cursed and decides to apple immediately to remove it, putting his enchanted apples on cool down. Said player then gets effected by mortal strike and can't eat an apple. If the player had waited he could have removed both curse and mortal strike. Maybe he did the right thing by using the apple earlier than later so he didn't take more damage from the time he was cursed till the time he was mortaled. Maybe not...? Difference in situations: Current situation Someone mortal strikes you. You get mortaled, eat an apple. It fails, so you eat another and another until the mortal strike is removed. You then get mortal striked again and your apple is on cool down. New situation Someone mortal strikes you. You eat an apple and mortal strike is removed. You then get moral striked again and your apple is on cool down. So there would be no difference in situations of being mortal spammed. Getting mortal spammed is the exact same either way. You eat an apple to remove mortal, apple goes on cool down, you get mortaled again. Both situations (old and new) result in the same out come. The suggested change effects nothing towards being spammed with debuffs, it would work exactly as it did before. All that would be changed is that instead of having to eat apple after apple and letting RNG be the deciding factor, instead we put more control to the player!!! Let the player chose when they want to apple, and face consequences if not choosing wisely! There are very strong points as to why they should be changed. More importantly, a lot of people think that this is going to change mechanics to the point where you will no longer be able to spam some debuff (such as mortal strike) on someone. If you read the situations above you can see that there is no change. Please add any of your concerns to this discussion in a civil manner. This is a PVP related discussion which usually turn into heated discussions. Let's try not to go that route!