I know its been said before... but will just headline again, in case a Dev may happen to look upon this page. Fish pies are pretty much useless the way they are.... They don't stack, so take up too much storage You can't eat them unless you are hungry, an orange or purple petal you can eat when you need it, and as soon as the effects of the petals wear off you can simply eat another. Cannot do this with fish pies, so in order to use them you would have to somehow make sure you are hungry at just the right time. I don't know about other peeps, but I generally make sure my warrior is well fed before going into a battle. Hence there goes the chance of being able to get any benefits from a fish pie. No one buys the fish pies, most likely due to the two reasons stated above.