You have no idea how hard this fish is to catch for me. I can catch two Holey Mackerels in the time I usually get the Siamese Cat Fish. My fishing uber Lady Fleabag started from Zippetyham and worked her way up the districts, almost hitting the F-district before FINALLY getting the stupid fish (that's 80 fish per district, excluding the inaccessible NR). I think there must be a factor with rods. This was the hardest time I've had with this, and she's been using a twig rod. Despite what they say, the bigger rods might make catching these easier. ie: It's POSSIBLE but not as likely.