Since the most recent slime spawned around chaos shrine I figured I could get on my red and try to finish the quest. I went to Jhelom and initiated the quest given by the NPC Lyla(?) and she gave me the 3 bowls. I have finished this quest on all my blue characters before, so I went to chaos and "dyed" the three bowls with acid slime and they turned into bloody water graphic as usual and I also hear the quest item sound. But after I take it back to the NPC it will not allow me to finish the quest for some reason. Anyone know why is this happening?